Offset or Digital Printing – Which is Best for Your Book?

Offset or Digital Printing – Which is Best for Your Book?

This is a guest post from Lori McKnight at MCRL Overseas Group.

Which is better offset or digital printing a book?

The decision to offset print or digitally print your book or planner ultimately depends on your business’ goals, needs, and budget.

One type of printing is not better than the other…the best choice truly depends on your situation. 

  • What’s your budget?
  • How many books or planners do you need?
  • What are your sales goals?
  • Are eco-friendly materials important?
  • Do you envision unique design and decorating features?
  • How much lead time do you have?

 

Image provided by MCRL Overseas Group

 

If you’re looking to print more than 300 books, planners or board books, then it’s worthwhile to get an offset printing quote. 

Not only is offset printing less expensive for higher print runs, it gives you many more options for:

  • paper stock 
  • PMS color matching Image provided by MCRL Overseas Group
  • non-standard sizes, including landscape books
  • unique features such as interactive flaps, textiles, branded pockets, tabs, glitter, etc. 

 

Alternatively, if you want to print under 300 books or planners that are standard size, without much customization then digital printing may be the way to go.

The Pros and Cons 

Offset Printing Pros

  • Most cost-effective for print runs > 300 books or planners
  • Highest quality printing with vibrant colors and crisp artwork
  • Wide range of paper stocks, custom options and eco-materials

Offset Printing Cons

  • Higher setup costs so uneconomical for print runs < 300 
  • Longer lead time 
  • Requires space to store inventory

Digital POD Printing Pros

  • Most cost-effective for small print runs
  • Faster turnaround as no set up is required
  • Print your books as you get orders (no inventory)

Digital POD Printing Cons

  • Cost per unit doesn’t change much with higher print runs
  • Profit margin is less 
  • Limited selection of cover materials, paper, finishes and add-ons

 

This comparison chart lists additional factors you may want to consider when determining the best type of printing and printing partner for your project.

 

chart comparing offset and digital printing

We recommend you get 2 quotes before making a final decision.
Thanks to MCRL Overseas Group for providing offset printing information

 

The Bottom Line

The best type of printing depends on your business goals and budget.

Digitally printing your book with vendors such as IngramSpark, Blurb, etc. will be less expensive than offset printing for small quantities.  

Offset printing more than 300 copies of your book or planner with an offset printer like MCRL Overseas Group will be significantly less expensive than digitally printing. And as your quantity increases, the unit price drops so your profit margin increases.

For a price comparison of offset printing and POD a hard cover and paperback book, download a Printer’s Guide to Offset Printing Your Book. During the 2024 WIP Summit, MCRL presented cost comparisons, printing tips and a guide to help you evaluate multiple printing quotes. https://www.mcrlprinting.com/wps/

 

Additional Resources 

Photo gallery of offset printed books & planners

Printing Terminology

 

 

WIP Sponsor Series: Understanding Your Offset Printing Quote

WIP Sponsor Series: Understanding Your Offset Printing Quote

Hosted by MCRL Overseas Group & BoardBookPrinting.com
Presenters: Taylor Watton & Lori McKnight

Hey authors and publishers! At some point, you may decide it makes more sense to do an offset print run (ie, a bulk print run that’s not through KDP or IngramSpark but a printing company) to reduce the costs associated with printing your book. You can often cut the print cost in half or more from the cost of Print on Demand Printers. The downside – you have to generally order a minimum of 500 books. However.. if you’re marketing, sending people to your website, selling books at events, the ability to double or triple what you’re making per book (sometimes more) – is worth ordering in bulk.

But wow, are there a lot of weird words and things you have to submit and the quotes are like reading a foreign language!

If you have ever looked at a print quote and felt overwhelmed, you’re not alone.

Join Taylor and Lori from MCRL, our featured partner printing company, as they explain key print terminology, show you how to spot hidden fees, and share smart tips to help you save—without compromising quality.

Learn what to look for beyond the numbers—because sometimes, what’s missing from your quote matters most.

🗓️ September 11
🕐 1 PM EST
💻 Register now!

What You’ll Learn:

  • Why and when to request a printing quote
  • Common terminology and what it means
  • Key factors that affect pricing (materials, finishes, quantities, etc.)
  • How to compare quotes and ask the right questions

Whether you’re a first-time customer or a seasoned print buyer, this session will help you make smarter, more strategic choices for your next project.

Lori is the marketing quarterback for MCRL Overseas Group and Boardbookprinting.com. Boardbookprinting.com is powered by the MCRL team, a Canadian-based offset printer of all genres of books from board books to yearbooks to notebooks to custom packaging, card sets, board games and more. Basically if you can think it, we can print it. Joining Lori, is our boardbookprinting.com lead – Taylor Watton.

Taylor is MCRL’s in-house board book expert and your main contact for questions, advice and quotes about printing your board book! Taylor and Lori are passionate about helping authors. With years of experience in the printing industry, they understand how overwhelming the process can be for authors—especially when it comes to board books. Their mission is to provide a seamless, positive experience that leaves authors excited and empowered to share their creations with the world.